Turner Hopkins - Barristers & Solicitors in Auckland

Big Brother May be Watching You!

Date: Wed, Sep 15th, 2010

Posted in: Employment Law - Employers

Big Brother

Personal comments are often posted with little thought as to the eventual audience. It is prudent therefore to think twice before posting that derogatory comment about a work colleague or your employer as it may lead to disciplinary action or at worst dismissal; particularly if the comment was posted during working hours!

The danger of indiscreet remarks posted on social networking sights was highlighted in the recent decision in Adams v Wellington Free Ambulance Service Incorporated. Ms Adams had been dismissed from her employment, following a dispute with a co-worker that spilled over into Facebook.

Ms Adams was found to have been unjustifiably dismissed, due to errors on the part of the employer in relation to the evidence that it considered in making the decision to dismiss her. However, her award was reduced by a total of 60% due to her contribution to the situation in which she found herself, and subsequently discovered misconduct on her part. With regard to the Facebook entries and in declining Ms Adams’ application for reinstatement, the Authority Member commented “Also significant is Ms Adams’ failure to understand that her interactions on Facebook were legitimate areas of concern for her employer… An employer is entitled (and indeed obliged if the issue relates to workers’ health and safety) to investigate problems between co-workers, even if the problems occur outside of work, especially if the genesis of those problems is the workplace. This is because such problems can clearly affect relationships in the workplace, which the employer is in control of and responsible for…”.

If you have encountered problems in the workplace, either as an employer or employee, please contact Helen Wendelborn or Michael Robinson of this office. We would be pleased to give you some practical advice on how to proceed.

Share this story:

Top of Page


Newsletter: Spring 2010

In this Issue

  • Big Brother May be Watching You!
    The internet is an indispensible tool and social networking sites such as Bebo, Facebook and Twitter are the forum of choice for this generation.
  • Directors Duties
    While companies provide limited liability and are considered a separate legal entity, directors can become personally liable if they breach their duties.
  • New Changes to Domestic Violence Law
    The new amendment to the Act brought into effect on 1 July 2010 bridges this gap and enables a qualified Constable to issue a Police Safety Order (“PSO”) on the spot.
  • New Form of Agreement for Sale and Purchase of Real Estate
    A New edition of the standard Agreement for Sale and Purchase of Real Estate has now been produced by the Auckland District Law Society and the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand Incorporated.
  • Staff News
    Turner Hopkins is very proud to announce the appointment of two of its staff members.
  • The Importance of a Current Will
    The recent High Court decision in re Trotter is a timely reminder of the importance of having a current Will, particularly for parties who have separated.
  • Trusts - Do You Need an Independent Trustee?
    An independent trustee is a person or corporate entity (company) who derives no benefit from the trust assets.
Spring 2010
Download Newsletter as PDF